Earnest Arthur Pie Society GraphicEarnest Arthur Pie Society GraphicEarnest Arthur Logo
Earnest Arthur Pie Society Logo

Gourmet pie delivery is coming to you

We're Earnest Arthur, a beloved South Coast pie destination. We've been in the pie game for nearly 30 years and now we're coming to your doorstep.

Choose eight Earnest Arthur pies and have them delivered to your door fortnightly, monthly or as a very good one-off decision. Join the waitlist for first access to the Pie Society.

Earnest Arthur Pie Society Pies
8 Pies in every box
Choose your own Flavours
Fortnightly, monthly or once-off
Delivering to Sydney & the South Coast
PROPERLY MADE SINCE 1997

Why these pies are different!

Our classic mince recipe is the same nostalgic flavour you've been craving since that road trip you took when you were a kid. We don't let that put us in a box though, our innovative gourmet pie recipes are tailored around quality ingredients, homestyle cooking, and ideas that don't always follow the status quo. Every flavour has its own story - and it doesn't make the cut unless it earns its place.

Earnest Arthur Pie Society Pies
YOUR PIE QUESTIONS

Pie Society FAQs

Here are some of the most common questions we get asked about the Pie Society. If you have a question that isn’t answered here, please get in touch and we’ll be happy to help.

FOUNDING MEMBERS WANTED

Be among the first invited to the table

Join the Earnest Arthur Pie Society waitlist for first access, launch updates and the opportunity to help shape the founding menu.

No payment. No commitment. Just first notice when the Society opens its doors.

By joining the club you will receive marketing material

©2026 Earnest Arthur. Privacy.